18 Bay

23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
631-749-0053
Price rangez: 
$$$
Hoursz: 
Dinner, Wednesday through Monday from 5:30 p.m. Sunday brunch, noon-3 p.m. Closed Tuesdays.

You know it’s haute cuisine when recipes include such exotic ingredients as stinging nettles. Elizabeth Ronzetti and Adam Kopels, the chefs and owners, who have considerable culinary training — he worked with Mario Battali, for example — moved their Bayville restaurant to what had been Planet Bliss on Shelter Island in 2011 and have been getting accolades ever since. The menu is small and changes weekly, in keeping with what is available locally. The island’s Sylvester Manor might send over chicory or Tuscan kale. A la carte ordering is possible only in the bar but guests go for the chef’s prix fixe dinner, at $55. It has four antipasti which might include house-made chicken and ramps sausage, followed by a pasta, which also is made in-house, and a choice of entree, which might be lamb loin or fluke or sea bass. One night dessert was strawberry-rhubard crostada with buttermilk ice cream. A vegetarian tasting menu is available.