Nick and Toni's

136 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937
631-324-3550
Price rangez: 
$$$
Hoursz: 
Dinner seven days in season from 6 p.m. Wednesday through Sunday off-season.

Nick and Toni’s has become almost as celebrated as the celebrities who frequent it. Aware that reservations can be very hard to get, Nick and Toni’s, which was renovated this spring, has added four high-top bar tables for walk-ins. The menu changes seasonally, making use of its own garden and produce and dairy from local farms. Wood-roasted whole fish is among the popular staples and tartufo has been a classic dessert for over a decade. As for libations, there are 15 wines by the glass and over 50 bottles for $50 or less, although it has rare finds for aficionados. Cocktails use fresh-squeezed juices, infused liquors, and ice orbs, and don’t forget the grappa.

Javascript is required to view this map.