Year round, and in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, Stars Cafe is a small, friendly, casual cafe with indoor and outdoor seating. Smoothies, a juice bar, and in-house roasted organic coffee are featured. Its local husband-and-wife owners are committed to homemade ingredients, whether in American or Latin dishes. Smoothies, organic juices, and the cafe's own roasted coffee are featured, along with desserts and warm pastries baked daily on the premises. In the warm months, the building's lower level becomes an ice cream shop.