Skip to main content

On the Police Logs 03.13.25

Thu, 03/13/2025 - 09:49

East Hampton 

An employee of East End Fuel on Springs-Fireplace Road reported to police on Feb. 25 that a customer had yet to pay a $1,490.90 bill for services. The customer gave a check to the company on Dec. 5, 2024, which bounced on Dec. 30 for insufficient funds, and bounced again on Jan. 7. The employee told police she’s tried contacting the customer several times but the bill has still gone unpaid.

The next day, Feb. 26, the manager of the North Main Street I.G.A. told police that a man had left the store without paying for items worth $33.97, including a deli sandwich, two hot lunches, and two sodas. The manager did not want to press charges, only to ensure that the man does not return to the store. 

Gunshots were reported in the late hours of March 4, by a resident of Two Holes of Water Road who told police he’d counted six shots coming from near his backyard. Upon investigation, officers found a man on Old Two Holes of Water Road who acknowledged shooting a pellet gun in his backyard. He apologized and promised to stop. 

East Hampton Village 

Police responded to a report of a fire at the Bank of America on Newtown Lane Friday evening. When police arrived the small “sod fire” had been extinguished, and fire chiefs concluded that a tossed cigarette was the cause. 

Montauk 

Low-flying drones were reported flying over Deep Hollow Ranch on the evening of March 3. Police saw their lights blinking red and white, but no action was taken. 

Sag Harbor 

A James Place woman reported a smell of gas in her house on the evening of March 4, and both police and firefighters responded. They found that the oven was on but did not smell gas, and turned off the gas flowing to the oven before leaving. 

An alarm went off at Harbor Market and Kitchen on the evening of March 5, but police found nothing out of the ordinary. The alarm company was contacted to tell an employee how to make the noise stop. 

Springs 

Flames were reported on Highwood Road Saturday might. Police found that a homeowner had been cooking over a fire pit in his backyard, and advised him to stop, due to strong winds and the danger of fire. He complied. 

A Gardiner’s Lane man called police last Saturday afternoon to say he’d been harassed over the phone. After leaving a casino earlier that day, he said, he went online to “arrange a meeting with an escort,” and sent $200 to someone in the Dominican Republic to receive the services. A man then called him, he said, demanding that more money be sent and threatening him. He was advised to stop all communication with the caller and block the phone number. 

Sentenced in P.T.A. Theft

Hope Livingston, a former Sag Harbor P.T.A. treasurer, was sentenced to five years of probation and restitution after pleading guilty to third-degree grand larceny and agreeing to a plea deal with county prosecutors. 

Oct 8, 2026

Brooklyn Woman Now in Double Trouble

A woman who is already in legal hot water with East Hampton Village seems to have found herself in more of it after a new arrest last Thursday.

Oct 8, 2026

Second Guilty Plea in Building Department Bribery Case

Ryan Benitez, a former East Hampton Town building inspector, admitted Thursday to accepting bribes in exchange for expediting building permits and certificates of occupancy in 2024 and early 2025.

Oct 1, 2026

Former Building Department Employee Pleads Guilty to Taking Bribes

Six months after her arrest, Evelyn Calderon, formerly of the East Hampton Town Building Department, took a deal in a Riverhead court Wednesday, pleading guilty to 10 counts of bribery and official misconduct. She was sentenced to 840 hours of community service, five years of probation, and a $29,200 fine. 

Oct 1, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.