Skip to main content

Former Montaukers Attacked

Thu, 06/08/2023 - 09:53

A GoFundMe campaign has been launched to raise money for members of a former Montauk family who were victims of a knife attack in Florida that police described as an attempted murder-suicide.

The St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office posted on its Facebook page that on Saturday at around 4:30 p.m., deputies responded to a call regarding a stabbing in Ponte Vedra, near Jacksonville. The sheriff’s office identified Spencer Ross Pearson, 18, as the suspect in “a targeted attack,” and said he was “known to the primary victim.”

That victim is Madison Schemitz, 17, who, according to the GoFundMe campaign, “was brutally attacked outside Mr. Chubby’s,” a restaurant, “with her mom, Jacki Roge.” Madison, one of six children, is a rising senior at Ponte Vedra High School. She “will have a long road to recovery as she is in critical condition” at Jacksonville Memorial Hospital. The family, longtime Montauk residents, moved to Florida a few years ago.

The News4Jax website, citing the sheriff’s office, reported on Monday night that Ms. Roge and Madison were at the restaurant on Saturday, and when they noticed Mr. Pearson at a nearby table they tried to avoid him and leave. Mr. Pearson followed them to the parking lot, where he attacked Madison, stabbing her at least 15 times. When Ms. Roge intervened, she was stabbed in the leg, forehead, and hand.

News4Jax said that Mr. Pearson “had reportedly been harassing the 17-year-old victim for two months.” WESH, a television station, identified Mr. Pearson as Madison’s ex-boyfriend.

On Monday, Ms. Roge posted on the GoFundMe page that “I am about to go into surgery, my muscles were severed from the bone on my hand. Madison has two chest tubes and a spinal cord injury, but she’s a fighter, just please continue praying for her.”

News4Jax had previously reported that two men arriving at the restaurant heard screams and intervened. One of them “saw a man on top of a woman on the sidewalk ‘pounding down on her chest,’ and he couldn’t tell if the man had a knife or was just using his fist, but he took off running and knocked the man off the woman.” In separating Mr. Pearson from Madison, he was slashed on the hand by the attacker, who then stabbed himself several times in the throat.

“All parties involved were transported to local area hospitals with serious injuries sustained from sharp force trauma,” the sheriff’s office posted. “Should the suspect survive his self-inflicted injuries, he will be charged with multiple felony charges, including attempted murder.”

The GoFundMe page is at bit.ly/3WSDbQX. As of Tuesday evening, 914 donors had raised $94,570. Efforts to reach family members on Monday and Tuesday were unsuccessful.

John Brady, a donor to the campaign, wrote on the page, “This family was a big part of my childhood growing up in Montauk and they are very special to my heart. Jacki, Madison & Chris [Schemitz, Madison’s father] . . . my prayers are with you and I can’t believe this. I will pray for your recovery, healing, and God willing, miracles, and ask anyone else to do the same.”

Villages

Herb’s Market Will Close Its Doors

Harold (Herb) Herbert opened Herb’s Market in 1963. It was a grocery store, deli, and butcher shop, and became an unofficial social center of Montauk — a place where both locals and visitors could gather, catch up with one another, share stories, and always feel welcome.

Sep 3, 2026

Careful Tick Checks the Only Solution

What’s the answer to the tick problem on the East End? Mountain lions? Genetically engineered mice? Deer-feeding stations? Deer-killing stations? Insecticides? All solutions were discussed at a talk sponsored by the Perfect Earth Project titled “Ticknology.”

Sep 3, 2026

Item of the Week: Annie Cooper Boyd’s Old Whalers Church

Her painting of Sag Harbor’s Old Whalers Church is dated Sept. 21, 1938, the day the Hurricane of 1938 hit, shearing off the 185-foot steeple.

Sep 3, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.