Built First, Now Approved
Built First, Now Approved
The East Hampton Village Design Review Board on Dec. 17 approved two houses already under construction in the Hedgerow subdivision on Sarah's Way.
The properties, numbers 6 and 14, are within the village's Main Street Historic District, created in 1986. Review Board approval, required before ground was broken, was overlooked by both the building code enforcement officer and the developer.
Robert Hefner, the village's consultant on historic preservation, told the board the development, barely visible from Main Street except for the rooftops, would "not detract" from the historic district.
Spacious "Cottages"
The houses, one at 9,000 square feet, the other 6,500 square feet, are both two-story, multi-gabled, "traditional" shingled structures.
Their size is not part of the Review Board's purview, Mr. Hefner said.
"This will be precedent-setting," announced Ina Garten, a board member.
Barnett Brown, Hedgerow's developer, who will live in 6 Sarah's Way and is building number 14, said none of the houses in the 10-lot subdivision would be less than 4,000 square feet.
All, he said, will have an "East Hampton cottage look."
Mr. Brown apologized to the board for overlooking the necessity to obtain a Review Board certificate of appropriateness. "My mind's overloaded," he said.
In other action, the Review Board approved a joint application from the East Hampton Historical Society and the East Hampton Garden Club to install a split-rail fence and plant several apple trees behind Rachel's Garden on the Mulford Farm, recreating a "remnant apple orchard."
The board also reviewed, but did not approve, an application by Power Test Realty Company, which owns the Getty station at the intersection of Montauk Highway and Toilsome Lane. The station's owners want to remove existing pumps, lighting, and signs, and replace them with new ones.
Board members were reluctant to approve the proposed lights, which would shine twice as brightly as the current ones, because the station is a pre-existing, nonconforming business in a residential neighborhood.