Skip to main content

Man's Recipe: Janet Spencer's Oil Dressing, 1954

Thu, 04/08/1954 - 10:56
From The East Hampton Star archive

There are 57-plus varieties of salad dressings, and some citizens I know are unconscionably stubborn about insisting that theirs is indisputably the world's best. I’m not going to be contumacious about it; all I am saying is that after testing and messing around with a few dressings, I know that this is the best one discovered to date.

Back in the 1910 era before we developed a vocabulary about vitamins, minerals, antibiotics, and molds, we had a chewy, tangy salad combination on the farm that Father and I thought tolerably good. It was a chopped-up mixture of cabbage and carrots and in addition Mother tossed on a few spoonfuls of sweet chutney. Then over the whole concoction she dowsed plenty of a sour cream dressing that was superb; not too sour, not too sweet; just right. That particular recipe is gone; I have never been able to find it, and my three sweet sisters, sweet most of the time except when they talk like sisters and try to reform me, cannot recall it either. One point puzzles me. If a man's wife has given up trying to reform him, why do his sisters keep up the fruitless struggle?

Janet's oil dressing has superb flavor, and if you have an I.Q. sufficiently high to chop your salads fine so you can efficiently get a load on your fork, you will like it. Use one cup salad oil, one third cup vinegar, one half cup tomato catchup, one teaspoon Worcestershire sauce, a medium-sized onion, one half cup sugar, and one teaspoon salt.

Cut the onion in small pieces. Mix all ingredients together and pour into a bottle. This recipe makes about a pint. Let the mixture stand a full week before using.

Why do I want my salads chopped fine? Listen, friends, there are more important things in my life than chasing a slippery, elusive, antagonistic leaf of greased lettuce around a plate. At the end of a hard day's work, I don't want to get tired out all over again eating salad.

Tags Recipes

News for Foodies 08.28.25

Pete Wells, former New York Times restaurant critic, comes to Guild Hall, South Fork Bakery operates a new cafe at the Rogers Memorial Library, and Feniks opens in Southampton.

Aug 28, 2025

Star Academy Students Toast Smokey Buns

Smokey Buns, a conveniently located burger joint, and Scoop and Waffle, a sweet little ice cream spot, off Park Place in East Hampton, were the perfect spots for the students of The Star’s Summer Academy to have a casual meal together on a Friday afternoon and try their hands at restaurant reviewing.

Aug 21, 2025

Local Peanut Butter Is Here

Walter Kim, a Sag Harbor resident, decided that if he wanted additive-free peanut butter, he would have to make and market his own. Enter Sagg Peanut Butter.

Aug 21, 2025

News for Foodies 08.14.25

Seafood paella is dished up every Wednesday evening at the fish farm on Napeague for as long as the weather permits.

Aug 14, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.