Skip to main content

Toward More ‘Enforceable’ Parking Rules in Montauk

Thu, 02/06/2025 - 09:23

East Hampton Town Councilman David Lys took his own projector to the first Montauk Citizens Advisory Committee meeting of the year to show the committee early plans to change the parking rules for several municipal lots throughout Montauk.

In this proposal, the currently unrestricted or unenforced parking rules in four large parking lots in Montauk would come to an end and parking would be limited to two hours, or in some cases 72 hours for those who have a valid East Hampton Town permit.

At present permit holders can park in these lots as long as they want with no restrictions. “This summer we found cars parked there with weeds underneath them,” Mr. Lys said.

Additionally the plans include the designation of five 30-minute parking spaces in the lot on South Euclid and South Embassy Streets near the police substation.

The other three municipal lots are located behind Main Street shops: one behind the former White’s Pharmacy, also on South Euclid Street, one by the Air and Speed Surf Shop on South Edison Street, and the last behind the Montauk Surf and Sports shop on South Embassy and South Elmwood Streets.

The present code is a mix of three different lines of legislation from 2011, 2013, and 2014, causing confusion and hindering enforcement, according to Mr. Lys.

Better enforcement is the impetus behind the changes. Mr. Lys spoke about looking over the code with East Hampton Town Police Chief Michael Sarlo and Sgt. Kenneth Alversa. Each deemed it “too ambiguous to enforce correctly.” For example the lot behind the former White’s Pharmacy right now has no enforceable parking restrictions.

“So you’re actually giving a time enforcement in an area that’s never had a time enforcement,” Mr. Lys said. 

A common question among the committee members was whether or not there would be long-term parking anywhere in Montauk if this is implemented.

“So where can residents put their cars long term,” asked Barbara Grimes, stipulating “more than 72 hours.” This question was later qualified by John Chimples.

“If all your proposals are implemented,” he asked, “where would someone go who wanted to park for a week?”

Mr. Lys gestured to street spots on the projected map that will, according to him, “remain unregulated.” Additionally right now there are parking spots along South Erie Street, from the public restrooms to the brewing company, that are unrestricted.

However, Mr. Lys indicated that the town is looking into eliminating overnight parking on that street, thus removing that option.

In terms of timing, Mr. Lys hopes that the town board will be able to have a public hearing on the changes in March, which would allow feedback from New York State to be returned and the changes implemented before the summer season begins.

Villages

Herb’s Market Will Close Its Doors

Harold (Herb) Herbert opened Herb’s Market in 1963. It was a grocery store, deli, and butcher shop, and became an unofficial social center of Montauk — a place where both locals and visitors could gather, catch up with one another, share stories, and always feel welcome.

Sep 3, 2026

Careful Tick Checks the Only Solution

What’s the answer to the tick problem on the East End? Mountain lions? Genetically engineered mice? Deer-feeding stations? Deer-killing stations? Insecticides? All solutions were discussed at a talk sponsored by the Perfect Earth Project titled “Ticknology.”

Sep 3, 2026

Item of the Week: Annie Cooper Boyd’s Old Whalers Church

Her painting of Sag Harbor’s Old Whalers Church is dated Sept. 21, 1938, the day the Hurricane of 1938 hit, shearing off the 185-foot steeple.

Sep 3, 2026

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.