Skip to main content

Merrall Topping Hildreth

Thu, 07/16/2020 - 12:58

Merrall Topping Hildreth, a descendant of a Hildreth who settled on Long Island in the 17th century, died gently at home in Sagaponack on July 5, his daughter, Deborah Hildreth Phelps of Columbia County, N.Y., said. He was 96 and had been in the care of East End Hospice for less than two weeks.

Mr. Hildreth's grandfather and great-uncle bought a building that housed a store and the Sagaponack Post Office in 1893. He owned and ran Hildreth & Company General Store with his wife and was the assistant postmaster, working for his father, the postmaster, until 1970, when he became postmaster himself. He remained in that position until 1986, when he retired. While his wife ran the store and he was alone in the post office, he took up whittling, a hobby he was good at and that he continued for the rest of his life. In 2001 he sold the building to his nephew Richard Thayer.

Born the second of six children on April 5, 1924, to Wallace Leland Hildreth and the former Elizabeth Vail, he grew up in Sagaponack, attending the Sagaponack Common School and graduating from Bridgehampton High School in 1942.

During World War II, Mr. Hildreth served in the Navy as an aviation machinist's mate aboard an aircraft carrier in the Pacific Theater, from November 1942 until mid-January 1946. He was honorably discharged and awarded a Silver Star, four Bronze Stars, and a Presidential Unit Citation Ribbon, the Navy's third highest individual award.

On June 25, 1950, he married Mary Lewis of Southampton Village, who survives. They had two daughters, Ms. Phelps and Donna Hildreth Moss, who died in 2000.

Mr. Hildreth was musical and played the violin as a child. He was also a natural athlete whose many pleasures included bowling -- he was on a team that competed for many years at East End Bowl -- golf, sailing, woodworking, and iceboating. He built his own boats in his barn by himself: iceboats, Sunfish, and a 20-foot cabin boat with outboard motor, in which the family spent weekends on Long Island Sound. When he was in his 70s, he helped his grandson, Eric Moss, build a boat in the barn.

 

People would drop by to visit, his daughter said, and ask what he was doing. He never had to ask for help; family and friends would help him pull the wood and clamp it, among other tasks. He enjoyed iceboating into his 80s, said Ms. Phelps. He also designed, built, and furnished numerous dollhouses, as well as replicas of the Hildreth store, the Sagg School, and the original Presbyterian Church in Bridgehampton. The Bridgehampton Historical Society held an exhibition of his wood carvings and model houses in 2011. He had an informal museum of his own making in the barn, with family heirlooms, antiques from the store, and items he had collected over the years. Groups of schoolchildren sometimes took field trips there. He carved animals and other figures in wood and also repaired customers' clocks, chairs, and other items that he would pick up while delivering orders, take away to fix at no charge, and bring back on the next delivery.

In addition to his wife and daughter, three grandchildren, Eleanor Phelps of Thailand (Sister Quang Son), Bree Moss of Florida, and Eric Moss of Wainscott, survive, as do two great-grandchildren.  His sister Mary Louise Hildreth Leonard of Sagaponack, a retired teacher, survives as well.

His sisters Ruth Hildreth Wiggins and Elizabeth (Betty) Hildreth, both of Sagaponack, and his brothers Wilbur Leland Hildreth of Glen Head and Charles Edward Hildreth of Bridgehampton, died before him, as did two nephews. Twelve nieces and nephews and many great-nieces and great-nephews survive.

The family held a private graveside service last Thursday at the family plot at Edgewood Cemetery in Bridgehampton, the Rev. Chuck Cary officiating. A Navy honor guard played Taps and presented an American flag to his wife.

Mr. Hildreth was a longtime member of the Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church and of the Sagaponack Cemetery Association, helping to maintain the grounds and raise and lower the flag. Memorial donations have been suggested to the church, at 2429 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton 11932, the cemetery association, c/o Jeff White, P.O. Box 298, Sagaponack 11962, or East End Hospice, P.O. Box 1048, Westhampton Beach 11978.

 

Villages

Rector of St. Luke's Takes Key Role in Coast Guard Chaplain Program

The Rev. Benjamin (Chaps) Shambaugh, who serves in the Coast Guard’s Auxiliary Chaplain Support program, became the branch chief of the Coast Guard’s Atlantic Area East on Jan. 1. In that role, he will oversee chaplains who care for Coast Guard members and their families from Canada to the Caribbean and in Europe and other areas abroad. 

Jan 10, 2025

Deep History in Sag Harbor Headstones’ Restoration

While Captain Beebee’s headstone now sits pristine atop the hill next to the Old Whalers Church, the rest of the family’s six plots sit in disrepair. Recently, however, the museum received a $10,000 grant from the Robert David Lion Gardiner Foundation, which will allow for the restoration of the remaining headstones.

Jan 9, 2025

Traffic-Calming Ideas for Wainscott

Looking ahead to the problem of summer traffic, David and Stacey Brodsky of Wainscott have a plan that they believe will alleviate the burden created by cars using some of the hamlet’s back roads to bypass Montauk Highway.

Jan 9, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.