Criminal Charges Dropped | The East Hampton Star

An East Northport man was cleared of criminal charges in East Hampton Town Justice Court last Thursday. Peter Louis Zarcone, who was 36 when he was arrested in Montauk last summer, had been charged by East Hampton Town police with two instances of criminal mischief at the felony level.

However, the district attorney’s office took the unusual step last Thursday in East Hampton Town Justice Court of agreeing to a plea bargain that not only dropped the felonies but skipped charges at the misdemeanor level in exchange for Mr. Zarcone pleading guilty to disorderly conduct as a violation and doing 21 hours of community service. As a result, he will not have a criminal record.

Police had arrested Mr. Zarcone based on a video of an incident in the parking lot of the 7-Eleven on Main Street. According to Mr. Zarcone’s lawyer, Michael Helfer, a video on the same surveillance camera cleared his client of deliberately damaging another man’s car, which was at the heart of the allegations. “There was a surveillance tape that exonerated him,” Mr. Helfer said afterward.

Mr. Zarcone will be allowed to perform the 21 hours of community service near where he lives.

Three Hurt in Two Collisions

A Nissan sedan collided with a Range Rover on Amagansett’s Main Street, and in Springs it was a BMW and a Buick.

Nov 13, 2025

On the Police Logs 11.06.25

An “older white man wearing a green hoodie and jeans” was wandering around his backyard, an Abraham’s Path resident reported Saturday. While an officer was en route, the resident called back to say that the man was a gardener.

Nov 6, 2025

Emergency Dispatch Cost Analysis Debated

With two months to go until the East Hampton Town Police Department takes over the lion’s share of emergency dispatching responsibilities from East Hampton Village, questions linger about the cost of the transition and how the town department will handle the new workload.

Oct 30, 2025

East Hampton Had Role in High-Stakes Poker Scandal

Rigged, illegal, and high-stakes poker games have been held in recent years in various locales, including East Hampton, according to a federal indictment filed on Oct. 9.

Oct 30, 2025

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.