Skip to main content

A 1749 Receipt From the Montauk Indians

Thu, 06/25/2020 - 10:18

East Hampton Library Item of the Week

This receipt is for a payment made by Burnet or Burnett Miller for 2 pounds, a payment on the 45 pounds "current money of New York" owed by the East Hampton Town Trustees to the Montauk Indians for the use of land on the Montauk peninsula. The receipt, dated April 24, 1749, indicates that Miller's money was received by "us whose names or mark are hereunto subscribed as Trustees in behalf of our selves and the rest of ye Indians belonging to Montauk." 

Thomas Hedges served as a witness, and four individuals were identified with the surname of "Indian." Not all of the Montauk signatories' names are fully legible, but two of them read as "John Indian" and "Peter Indian." Many accounts identify local indigenous people with such a surname. It's possible one of the other names is a phonetic spelling, but it's unclear. 

The Montauks who "signed" this document did not use pictographs, but rather a simple mark instead. Other documents signed by members of the Montauk people sometimes include a pictograph-like recognizable signature, but a mark was common for those who were not literate. Typically, the Montauk Indians would sell the trustees and settlers access to land for cattle grazing. 

Miller was a prominent resident of East Hampton. Born in 1719, he held the position of town supervisor from 1764 through 1776. He served in the Revolutionary War, and took part in the battle at Ticonderoga. After the war, he and some of his family settled in Plattsburgh, N.Y., where he died in 1797.

This document is part of the Proprietors of Montauk Collection. The Long Island Collection joined with the Brooklyn Historical Society in scanning documents in both their collections and ours to increase access for researchers. Other receipts for payment to the Montauk Indians also appear within the Proprietors of Montauk Collection, beginning with the first payment in 1703 and continuing through 1773.


Andrea Meyer is the head of collection for the East Hampton Library's Long Island Collection. Questions and suggestions can be emailed to [email protected].

Villages

Owl's Death Prompts Call for Bird-Friendly Building

Window strikes kill up to a billion birds annually and rank up there with cats and habitat destruction as the leading causes of recent steep declines. After the recent death of a much-watched Eurasian eagle-owl that was set loose from the Central Park Zoo, a bill calling for bird-friendly building measures has been revived in the New York Assembly and Senate.

Mar 28, 2024

Architect’s Descendants Visit East Hampton Gem

Michele L’Hommedieu Hofmann had no idea until retiring last fall and starting to research her family history how prominent a role her great-great-grandfather James H. L’Hommedieu had played in Long Island’s late-19th-century architecture. On a trip to New York that included a stop at an East Hampton house he designed for Robert Southgate Bowne, a founder of the Maidstone Club and first president of the Long Island Rail Road, she and her family got a crash course in L’Hommedieu’s work.

Mar 28, 2024

Item of the Week: Gardiner Family Gossip From 1889

On July 16, 1889, while staying in Lenox, Mass., Sarah Diodati Gardiner Thompson wrote to her daughter Sarah Thompson Gardiner, who was vacationing at Lake Winnipesaukee in New Hampshire. Family news was top of mind.

Mar 28, 2024

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.