Skip to main content

Gardiner’s Buffalo and Barns, 1893-1904

Thu, 07/25/2024 - 08:40

Item of the Week
From the East Hampton Library
Long Island Collection

This photograph, which was lent to the Long Island Collection for digitization, shows David J. Gardiner’s livestock in front of his barns. Gardiner (1840-1924) sold his proprietorship of Gardiner’s Island to his brother, John Lion Gardiner, and lived in the Gardiner Brown House, at 95 Main Street in East Hampton Village, with these barns on the property.

David’s land holdings were among the most extensive in East Hampton, his property stretching from Main Street back to the railroad station. He operated several businesses, including the East Hampton Lumber & Coal Company, and he maintained a strong interest in farming and horse breeding.

Gardiner’s buffaloes were a local novelty. Some of his herd came back from the West with him, and some were given to him in March of 1893 by Austin Corbin (1827-1896), robber baron and president of the Long Island Rail Road, from Corbin’s game preserve in New Hampshire. Gardiner tried to mate the buffaloes with local cattle, producing a mule-like breed called a cattalo. Gardiner’s buffalo experiment ended in 1904, with his remaining cattaloes donated to the Bronx Zoo.

After David Gardiner died in 1924, his nephew Winthrop Gardiner Sr. (1887-1970) inherited the Gardiner Brown House and undertook important renovations to the property, which mainly relied on well water, with minimal heating. Winthrop Gardiner moved the house significantly back from the street as part of his renovations.

In 1928, at least one of the barns from the property was moved down Main Street and Newtown Lane to 4 Fresno Place, where it still stands. At this site, Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps show that the property was owned by the Barns family between 1929 and 1957 and used for their masonry business. 

In 1962, Bruce Collins bought the property from Robert S. Barns, a builder, in the interest of expanding operation space for his family’s oil business, Collins Fuel Inc. The barns and the property where they stand on Fresno Place are now for sale.

Andrea Meyer, a librarian and archivist, is head of collection for the East Hampton Library’s Long Island Collection.

Villages

Montauk Playhouse Work Will Be Done by June

Construction of the new aquatic and cultural spaces at the Montauk Playhouse Community Center is slated to be done by the end of June, according to Sarah Iudicone, president of the Montauk Playhouse Community Center Foundation. The date for the public opening, however, is still up in the air.

Apr 3, 2025

Days of Crime and Mystery

Hamptons Whodunit, a mystery and true-crime festival now in its third year in East Hampton Village, kicks off with a cocktail party at the Maidstone Club next Thursday evening and continues with three days of discussions, tours, book signings, and interactive events.

Apr 3, 2025

Item of the Week: Home, Boarding House, Cottage, Rectory

Bridgehampton’s Atlantic House is an excellent example of the tradition of structural reuse hereabouts.

Apr 3, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.