Long Island Larder: Christmas Fare
Long Island Larder: Christmas Fare
The catalogues stacked by the chimney with care
And the credit cards ragged
with far too much wear. . .
It's too late to force bulbs
or "Martha" your house
So give up, think sweet thoughts,
make desserts, reservations,
or fly down to Peru.
Christmas dinner is the next major feast we tackle, and it's a lot more variable than the Thanksgiving menu, which is more or less set in stone by most families.
In my household, we opt for the English traditional roast beef (the Dickensian goose having always disappointed everyone). In the South, the main attraction was often a country ham; in New England, the turkey again - if you're lucky, a wild one - or some venison.
A special lasagne is not unheard of at some Italian holiday tables and leg of lamb stars at Christmas dinner for many families of various ethnic backgrounds.
Left to my own devices, I'd probably go with buckwheat blini and caviar, smoked salmon, and champagne. But I am never allowed my own devices.
Dessert was traditionally fruitcake, mince pie, or English plum pudding at my mother's Christmas table. I loathed fruitcake and dropped that item as soon as humanly possible.
However, the mince pie is still a "must" around here, and last year I made my own version of plum pudding.
Those who eyed it dubiously at first wound up asking for seconds.
Anyway, the holly and the flames are good dinner-theater.
Plenty Of Time
Like fruitcake, old recipes admonish the cook to make plum puddings months ahead of time.
But it really isn't necessary, and the beauty part is that you can make this any time from now up until a couple of days before Christmas.
If you have a pressure-cooker, you won't have to simmer it in the oven for hours, but even so, you just go about your business while the pudding throbs along all by itself to a delicious, dense taste thrill.
A pressure-cooker contracts the steaming time from about six hours to 90 minutes.
Christmas Plum Pudding
1 cup dried currants
1/2 cup dried Sultanas (yellow raisins)
1/2 cup dried apricots, chopped
1/2 cup dried pears, chopped
1 cup unbleached flour
2 cups bread crumbs (from day-old bread)
2 sticks unsalted butter or 1/2 lb. fresh beef suet, finely chopped
Peel of one orange, grated
Juice of one orange
Peel of one lemon, grated
11/4 cups raw sugar or light brown sugar
1/8 tsp. ground nutmeg or mace
4 beaten eggs
1/2 cup dark rum
Mix, Cover, Steam
Mix all the ingredients in the order given and scrape into a buttered eight-cup mold or heavy, heatproof china bowl. The pudding will expand, so the dish shouldn't be filled higher than an inch below the top rim. Cover it, first with buttered parchment (or typing) paper, then with heavy aluminum foil tied tightly with string.
Set the pudding on a rack in a pot that has about an inch of space all round it and fill it half to three-quarters of the way up with boiling water. Cover the steaming vessel and place it in the lower third of the oven (pre-heated to 325 degrees F.). After half an hour, lower heat to 300 degrees. Steam the pudding for six hours. When done, store it with fresh, dry coverings in a cool, dry place (not the refrigerator) until a couple of hours before serving.
Re-immerse the pudding in its boiling-water bath and steam it for about an hour. Lift it out, unmold it onto a heavy platter, and place a holly sprig on top. Heat a quarter-cup bourbon in a ladle and when it flames, pour it over the pudding. Rush it to the table before the flames die out.
Hard Sauce
Serve it with hard sauce, either purchased or easily made in a food processor. This can be made a week ahead of time, refrigerated, then brought to room temperature and beaten lightly to serve. It melts on top of the hot plum pudding; very little is needed for each portion.
1/2 lb. unsalted butter
1 cup light brown sugar
Pinch of salt
Pinch of nutmeg
1/4 cup bourbon or cognac or brandy
Cream the butter and sugar with the salt and nutmeg in a food processor or electric mixer (this ancient sauce can, of course, be made with a bowl and a wooden spoon). When light and fluffy, add the liquor in a slow stream. Pile into a container, cover, and store until needed.
The Right Dish
This next dessert is light, fluffy, and simple to make. I added pears to the basic pudding, normally made with rum-soaked raisins, which I've never cared for. Use either fresh Bosc pears or dried pears (moist, not leathery ones).
My pudding dish is Bennington stoneware, round, and about 12 inches in diameter by 21/2 inches deep. However, an oblong 9-by-13 standard glass baking dish could be substituted if you don't mind the somewhat institutional look of it.
Any kind of heatproof baking bowl or dish will do, actually, though it should not be too deep or the edges of the pudding will dry out before the center is cooked enough. Don't substitute any kind of fancy bread, though, such as baguettes or sourdough, because they won't make a proper fluffy pudding.
Southern Bread Pudding With Pears
Serves 12.
1 large, medium-ripe Bosc pear, peeled, cored, and sliced or 3/4 cup dried pears, snipped into small pieces
1 loaf Pepperidge Farm "toasting" white bread, (to make about 8 cups torn into bite-size pieces, with crusts on)
5 cups whole milk
1 cinnamon stick
1/2 vanilla bean
6 extra-large eggs
1 cup white sugar
Butter
Spread the pear slices on a lightly oiled shallow pan or cookie sheet. Bake at 300 degrees for about an hour. Remove and cut in small pieces. Set aside.
Be Gentle
Tear up the bread. Heat the milk with the cinnamon stick. Split the bean and scrape the vanilla pulp into the milk and toss in the bean. Bring it to just under the simmer and hold it at that temperature for 15 minutes. Do not boil.
Meanwhile, beat the eggs together with the sugar in a large bowl. Remove the cinnamon stick and vanilla bean from the scalded milk and pour it into the center of the eggs and sugar, whisking gently (you don't want a froth) constantly.
Pour this over the torn bread, stir in the pears, and let it soak for 10 or 15 minutes. Turn this into a prepared baking dish, well coated with soft butter. Dot with a bit more butter.
Preheat the oven to 350 F.
Let The Ends Hang Out
Put the pudding into an underpan with at least an inch of space around the perimeter of the pudding so that you can lift it out. With a round, handleless dish, place a folded thin cloth under it before setting it into the underpan. Leave the ends hanging out for lifting handles.
Pour boiling water around the pudding and place it in the center of the oven. In 10 minutes, reduce the heat to 325 and bake about 35 to 40 minutes - until a table knife inserted in the center comes out fairly clean. Do not overbake.
The pudding will need to cool on a rack for half an hour before serving with Whiskey Sauce. Or, it can be refrigerated, then reheated in a water bath (as above) before serving.
Whiskey Sauce
This sauce is mounted rather like a beurre blanc but is far less tricky to make. Just make sure the bottom of the double-boiler never actually touches the barely simmering water beneath it, or scrambled eggs will happen. It reheats easily by whisking it over very hot water.
If you're the type who wears suspenders and a belt, make the sauce in a heavy china bowl set over a smaller pot of barely simmering water.
1 extra-large whole egg
1 egg yolk
1/2 cup sugar
1 stick room-temperature unsalted butter, cut into 8 pieces
Pinch of nutmeg
1/4 cup bourbon
Lightly whisk the egg, yolk, and sugar together in the top part of a double boiler (or heavy china bowl). Set it over barely simmering water in the bottom part of the boiler and whisk gently, adding one piece of butter at a time until all is incorporated. Whisk in nutmeg and bourbon and pour into a slightly warmed sauceboat with a small silver ladle.
Only a little of this potent sauce is necessary to top each serving of pudding.