Smokers' Bar Is Just About The Last of Its Kind, Cognac drinkers already in bed when it gets going
Smokers' Bar Is Just About The Last of Its Kind, Cognac drinkers already in bed when it gets going
When Arlene Furer opened the Cigar Bar in Sag Harbor 10 years ago she thought that her patrons would be "high-end cigar smokers and cognac drinkers." As it turned out, "that crowd is already in bed" by the time her business starts to pick up. The bar, she said recently, has taken on "an identity of its own."
That identity means one thing to Ms. Furer and something else to the Sag Harbor Village police, who visit the Cigar Bar regularly over reports of stolen wallets and purses or fights among patrons. Since Memorial Day weekend, code enforcement officers have issued several summonses for alleged overcrowding and citations for fire code violations.
Tucked next to La Superica restaurant at the north end of Main Street, the Cigar Bar serves from 2 p.m. to 4 a.m. all the usual drinks plus concoctions such as a "hot and dirty martini" for $10. From 6 a.m. until 2 p.m., customers can buy tea or Starbucks coffee from a server in the bar's entryway.
The bar, which has a maximum legal occupancy of 28, is one of only two places in Suffolk County left where patrons can legally drink and smoke at the same time. New York's Clean Indoor Air Act allows smoking in public places only in cigar bars or smoking establishments that existed in December 2002.
The bar's decor includes six stools, several small velveteen sofas, like those seen in brothels in Hollywood westerns, and a few rugs.
There is also a walk-in humidor with glass doors and windows; it contains "many, many shelves of premium cigars," Ms. Furer said. Several varieties of cigarettes are also sold at the bar.
Ms. Furer said that her customers are a diverse lot, adding that she once counted people of 15 different nationalities on the premises. Summertime brings people from all over the world who have docked their boats in Sag Harbor, added to regulars who live on the South Fork. The locals have the place to themselves in the doldrums of February.
At around 11:30 on a recent Friday night, a little more than 30 people were scattered around the bar. Two young women with blond hair and tight jeans danced sinuously near the window. Three men dressed in hip-hop style slumped in stuffed chairs at the bar's entrance, and a man in his late 50s, standing alone near a column, bobbed his head to the thumping music, dragging deeply on a cigar.
A group of people were lined up at the bar, yelling orders over the music, as a gaggle of people in their 30s with the air of visitors to the village spilled in from the street. There were no fights, no cries of theft; then again, it was still early.
The problem, said Sag Harbor officials, is that the pleasures of a late night bar don't always coincide with the aims of police, government, and village residents.
Sag Harbor Village Police Chief Thomas Fabiano said in June that things "seem to be getting progressively worse" at the bar.
At 3 a.m. on June 8, police were called about a "verbal dispute" among patrons. No one was hurt and no charges were filed. But on May 16 at 4 a.m., one patron allegedly threw a bottle at another, and a 24-year-old Wisconsin resident was charged with a misdemeanor count of assault. Police said that his alleged victim was treated at the hospital and released.
On May 8 at 12:30 a.m., police were also called to the bar because of a fight, this one resulting in "minor wounds." No charges were filed.
Thefts are not uncommon, and usually involve purses and wallets, police said, although on one occasion a patron's nail gun was taken after he placed it on the bar. Bryon Connolly, a former Cigar Bar employee, claimed that a customer's laptop computer was stolen.
"I'm sure it happens," Ms. Furer said. "Alcohol impairs the judgment."
Sag Harbor Village Mayor Edward Deyermond has said that overcrowding is a problem at the bar, but Ms. Furer said on June 3 that her bartenders "are strictly enforcing" the 28-person limit. On weekends, she added, an employee stands at the door to check customers' IDs and control any fights that break out.
Timothy Platt, the Sag Harbor code enforcement officer and fire marshal, visited the Cigar Bar on the Friday, Saturday, and Sunday of Memorial Day weekend. All three nights, he said, the bar exceeded its occupancy limit - by 12, 17, and 20 people.
After the first night, Mr. Platt warned bar employees that he would return on Saturday and Sunday. Still, the bar was overcrowded, and summonses were issued for those nights. The bar has also been cited for fire code violations, but quickly complied with the regulations, he said.
Mayor Deyermond said that the bar has established an illegal "patio" in the parking lot behind the restaurant. Mr. Connolly claimed that a back door was left open so that when code enforcement officers arrived, customers could be hustled out of the bar room itself.
Mayor Deyermond said that if chronic overcrowding continues, the village will bring a suit against the Cigar Bar in Southampton Town Justice Court. "We want to enforce our zoning codes and we'll do what he have to," he said.
Ms. Furer said she was negotiating with the village to remove some of the bar's seats in order to increase its maximum occupancy. For each seat she removes, she can add two to the number, she said, adding that she would be willing to take out all the couches and bar stools.
Such an effort could constitute an expansion of the bar under the restrictive rules that govern cigar bars, however, according to Mayor Deyermond, and would mean that Ms. Furer would lose her license as a smoking establishment.
For now, Ms. Furer is simply trying to run a business, and the Cigar Bar, she said, is not about police reports and code enforcement visits. "It's about meeting great people. This place is about everyone having fun."