East End Eats: Service Station: Fill ’Er Up, Please!
East End Eats: Service Station: Fill ’Er Up, Please!

Service Station
100 Montauk Highway
East Hampton
631-267-5603
Lunch and dinner daily Once upon a time there was a restaurant in East Hampton called Nichol’s. It was tiny and cozy and chock full of Anglophilia and served good pub grub. The drinks were cheap and large, wine served in goblets, beer by the bucket. It was popular with those who appreciate good value. It changed hands a few times. For a while it was Winston’s, with the same decor but with a few Jamaican accents added to the menu and decor. Winston’s was good, but now it is the Service Station and it is better.
The warren of small rooms has been opened up and lightened. The floors and trim are dark, the walls off-white, and there are a few hints that this location was, in fact, once a service station, such as the old-fashioned bell hose outside that gives a little “ding ding” when you walk or drive over it.
There is a nice outdoor patio next to the parking lot for those who don’t mind dining 20 feet from the zoom-zooming traffic of Route 27. The inside is still cozy but now feels bigger. There is an attractive copper bar in the back with two big flat screen TVs.
We began our meal with very reasonable, very good cocktails, along with Caesar salad, calamari, beef satay, and spinach artichoke dip. Now, I consider myself quite a connoisseur of Caesar salad. I make it at home all the time and feel very strongly about the balance of flavors. It must be lemony and garlicky and have at least a whisper of anchovies. A somewhat creamy consistency is good, homemade croutons a must, and it needs just the right amount of freshly grated Parmesan cheese. The Service Station version was most excellent — tart, flavorful, well-balanced dressing on a whole wedge of crisp romaine with house-made croutons. We all agreed it was just right.
The calamari was also very good and a good-size portion. One of the best parts about it was the addition of string beans, lemon slices, and strips of peppadew peppers that had also been fried with the calamari. It was served with a slightly spicy sriracha aioli. But the aspect that really caught our (okay, just my) attention was the spectacular batter on the squid and its little vegetable buddies on the plate. Extra crunchy and savory, it was so good it convinced us to order more fried stuff, as in chicken. More on that later.
The beef satay was also delicious: six skewers with tender, marinated grilled meat and a zesty peanut sauce. It was almost as tender as filet, but I’m guessing it was hanger or skirt steak. The spinach artichoke dip (compliments of the management because one of our guests is a friend) was served in a warm ramekin with creamed spinach on the bottom and marinated, chopped artichokes and red onion on top. The fried flour tortillas served alongside were a good accompaniment.
For entrees we tried the fish tacos, seared scallops, Lee Roy’s Southern-fried chicken sandwich, and a special of that evening of chicken thighs with polenta.
The two codfish tacos were on grilled flour tortillas with a creamy slaw, pico de gallo, and a tart avocado sauce. They were very good.
The scallop dish was pretty good but a bit messy, as was the chicken thigh dish. Both were completely covered with a layer of arugula. The scallops were tender and cooked properly, but my guest found them to be a bit sweet. The corn orzo served underneath was pretty good, but the big leaves of curly kale didn’t add anything. The Southern-fried chicken sandwich was a winner. It was served on a brioche bun with a tomato slice, red onion, lettuce, more great slaw, and a hidden treat of pancetta bacon. Once again, the batter on the chicken was superb. The sandwich also came with a little basket of excellent skin-on French fries.
The chicken thigh special was tasty, but as I mentioned before, the huge layer of arugula covering the whole dish made it hard to navigate slicing the meat. But the flavors were good — creamy, somewhat cheesy polenta with boned, very crisp thighs, and a slightly sweet glaze.
Service on the night of our visit was excellent, and the place filled up quickly. Our waiter, Dominique, was helpful and knowledgeable, and one of the owners visited our table several times. It was a happy, professional, and welcoming environment.
Prices are reasonable. Starters and salads are $10 to $17, main dishes are $17 to $26, sides are $6 to $8, kids’ menu items are $10, and desserts are $9 and $10.
For dessert we ordered the brownie sundae and strawberry rhubarb pie. The cookies and brownies are made in house. The brownie sundae had a very good fudgy brownie with chocolate chips, along with a premium dark chocolate ice cream and vanilla ice cream. I’m not sure where the strawberry rhubarb pie came from, but it was tart and fresh with a good flaky crust. The slice was enough for two people.
The Service Station offers very, very good comfort foods at reasonable prices and is a family-friendly place. What kid wouldn’t love getting “breakfast for dinner”?!
I was never a fan of fare at Nichol’s, and I admit I will miss Winston’s jerk chicken, but the Service Station is just what we need out here: open every day, year round. Fill ’er up? Yes, please.