Skip to main content

Four Police Officers Are Honored

Wed, 02/12/2025 - 22:14
East Hampton Town Police Officer Nicole Fierro had a “tremendous year,” having led the department in drunken-driving arrests, responding to over 1,000 calls, and leading in arrest assists, according to Chief Michael Sarlo, left.

The Southampton Town Kiwanis Club honored police officers from both East Hampton Town and Village at an awards dinner on Jan. 31, with Nicole Fierro winning Officer of the Year for the town and three officers taking home the same award for the village.

The village officers, Sgt. Wayne Gauger, Officer John Clark, and Officer Robert Greene, were recognized for their roles in the Aug. 31 arrest of Alexis Ramirez-Reyes, a Bridgehampton man who reportedly reached for a loaded handgun during a scuffle with the trio.

Having pulled Mr. Ramirez-Reyes over for “inadequate” taillights and having an “obstructed view,” Officer Clark noticed an “AR-15 style rifle” on the floor, which he later determined was an airsoft gun. Then, Sergeant Gauger and Officer Greene arrived at the scene as backup.

When Mr. Ramirez-Reyes “refused” to leave the vehicle, the officers grabbed his hands and pulled him to the ground, at which point Mr. Ramirez-Reyes allegedly reached for the Glock 19, which later proved to be loaded with a live 9-millimeter round.

“You never know with traffic stops,” said Lt. Jack Bartelme, about the village award. “You don’t know what you’re going to come across. Every stop can be different.”

Out here, “it’s not common, guns on people.” Nonetheless, the lieutenant said, “We’re happy in the outcome — happy no one got hurt.” Later, he said, the department discovered that Mr. Ramirez-Reyes had gang ties. As of now, the case is still pending in the Suffolk County Criminal Court system.

For the town, Chief Michael Sarlo said in an email that Officer Fierro had a “tremendous year,” having led the department in drunken-driving arrests for the past two years. Over that same period, she has responded to over 1,000 calls, and led the department in arrest assists, meaning she is a “team player and always there for her fellow officers.”

“We get a lot of positive feedback from the community regarding her professional demeanor and willingness to go above and beyond for people with the little things that often go unnoticed,” the chief said.

Ups and Downs in Annual Police Report

East Hampton Town police made fewer overall arrests last year, but more arrests for driving while intoxicated — another year that has led Chief Michael Sarlo to say that “we live in an extremely safe community.” 

Mar 13, 2025

On the Police Logs 03.13.25

Low-flying drones were reported flying over Deep Hollow Ranch on the evening of March 3. Police saw their lights blinking red and white, but no action was taken. 

Mar 13, 2025

Family Dog Perishes in East Hampton House Fire

A fire on Park Street in East Hampton early Saturday afternoon left extensive damage to a house and killed the family dog, East Hampton Fire Chief Duane Forrester said Monday. 

Mar 11, 2025

East Hampton Village Eyes Its Own Justice Court

East Hampton Village is exploring creating its own justice court that could be up and running at the Emergency Services Building on Cedar Street by next January.

Mar 6, 2025

 

Your support for The East Hampton Star helps us deliver the news, arts, and community information you need. Whether you are an online subscriber, get the paper in the mail, delivered to your door in Manhattan, or are just passing through, every reader counts. We value you for being part of The Star family.

Your subscription to The Star does more than get you great arts, news, sports, and outdoors stories. It makes everything we do possible.