Skip to main content

Police & Courts

Arrests Signal Busy Season Ahead

Despite the cold, rainy weather, a number of arrests over the last week signaled the start of the busy season on the South Fork.

Jun 4, 2021
On the Police Logs 06.03.21

A Maidstone Avenue woman told police on May 26 that her neighbor had moved survey stakes a foot or so from where they belonged, making her property that much smaller. She was advised that it was a civil matter.

Jun 4, 2021
On the Road and on the Water

Joseph Keane of Amagansett, 59, was driving a 2013 Toyota at about 5:30 p.m. on May 22 when, headed west on Amagansett Main Street, he attempted to make a left turn toward Bluff Road and struck a telephone pole. Mr. Keane, who has a previous conviction for driving while intoxicated within the past 10 years, could not perform roadside sobriety tests, reported East Hampton Town police, who charged him with felony D.W.I.

Jun 3, 2021
'Unprecedented Challenges' for Police in the Pandemic

Despite the unprecedented challenges of policing during a pandemic and nationwide scrutiny in the wake of multiple civilian deaths while in police custody, Chief Michael Sarlo was upbeat in summarizing the East Hampton Town Police Department's annual report to the town board.

Jun 3, 2021
Kiteboarder and Rafters Rescued in Rough Weather

Two saves on the water over the holiday weekend were efficient and without major injury, a good warm-up for chaotic summer months likely to come. One involved a kiteboarder tangled in his equipment and the other a pair of inflatable boats, each with five people on board, that were caught in two-to-three-foot waves in significant winds.

Jun 2, 2021
On the Police Logs

Highlights of a quiet week included a report of "a dog appearing to be a pit bull" wandering on Newtown Lane without an owner at 9 p.m. on May 17. Police did not find it.

May 27, 2021
Restitution Agreement Reached in Fraud Case Involving Former Radio Station Manager

Stephanie McNamara Bitis, a former general manager of Long Island Radio Broadcasting, admitted in November to using a company credit card for more than 600 personal expenses, but it wasn't until last week that her attorney and the assistant United States attorney prosecuting the case agreed on the exact dollar figure involved.

May 24, 2021
D.W.I. Charges for Two Drivers

Police this week charged one person with driving while intoxicated and booked seven others on traffic and trespassing misdemeanors.

May 20, 2021
On the Police Logs 05.20.21

"Three images of the male genitalia were spray-painted on either end of the fence" at 7 North Main Street on May 10, East Hampton Village police reported.

May 20, 2021
Jogger Injured in Accident

East Hampton Town Police reported that on the evening of May 12, Hai Cao of Amagansett did not see a jogger as he turned left in his 2015 Toyota from Cedar Street onto Osborne Lane in East Hampton. Mr. Cao reportedly said to police that his view was limited and by the time he saw the jogger, Tint Juri of East Hampton, crossing from one side of Osborne Lane to the other, he could not avoid hitting him.

May 20, 2021
Statutory Rape Is Alleged

After receiving a complaint last Thursday night concerning a sexual relationship between a 26-year-old man and a minor under the age of 17, East Hampton Town police arrested Byron Torres of Daniel's Hole Road in Wainscott on charges of statutory rape. Contact between the two, police said, was from around Feb. 1 to April 30.

May 20, 2021
Minor Damage at Moby's After Early Morning Fire

"We're grateful that the small fire at the restaurant last week caused only minimal damage and everyone is safe, thanks to our local firefighters who acted quickly," a spokesperson for the restaurant said yesterday. "We're working closely with the Town of East Hampton . . . to reopen better than ever by Memorial Day weekend. We'll know the exact date shortly of our reopening next week, and will share on @mobysny once we're able to confirm."

May 14, 2021
On the Police Logs 05.13.21

The second jetty at Georgica Beach was slippery on Friday morning, to which the man who fell and pulled a muscle in his right quad might attest. He called in to ask for help getting off the beach, “so he could get medical attention on his own,” police said.

May 13, 2021
First Responders Awarded For Dramatic Rescue

When a woman was dropped off unresponsive in the foyer of East Hampton Town police headquarters in Wainscott in February of last year, "that was my first experience of something like that," said Detective Michael Coleman, one of the officers who rushed to the front of the building.

May 13, 2021
Low-Flying Pilot Arraigned

David Wisner, the low-flying pilot who was charged with second-degree reckless endangerment after buzzing Sag Harbor at around 5:30 p.m. on April 13 and, minutes before that, areas of Springs, was arraigned on May 7 in Sag Harbor Village Justice Court for the alleged misdemeanor. Mr. Wisner's 90-day ban from East Hampton Airport is ongoing. Court conferences begin on July 2; meanwhile, the Federal Aviation Administration is still investigating the incident.

May 13, 2021
On the Police Logs 05.06.21

With the onset of warmer weather, once again comes news of rental scams on the South Fork. One was reported in Montauk this week.

May 6, 2021
D.W.I. Charge in Speedway Lot

Two men were ticketed for allegedly driving while intoxicated in East Hampton Town this week.

May 6, 2021
Sentencing Postponed in Credit Card Fraud Case

The sentencing of a former Long Island Radio Broadcasting executive for credit card fraud has been postponed while the defense and prosecution dispute the amount of money involved in the crime.

May 6, 2021
Interlock Device Was Needed

Town police reported the arrest of a man in East Hampton on the morning on April 27 on a misdemeanor charge of driving a vehicle not equipped with an interlock device, which is needed to turn over the engine of a car driven by someone previously convicted for driving while intoxicated.

May 6, 2021
Crash Briefly Closes Eastbound Montauk Highway in Water Mill

Eastbound Montauk Highway in Water Mill reopened at approximately 10:30 a.m. Monday following a crash involving a motorcycle, according to Lt. Susan Ralph of the Southampton Town Police Department. Injuries were minor, she said.

May 3, 2021
Drivers Without Paperwork on Local Roads

One airplane-related arrest last week, covered separately on this page, was the only break from the usual reports of road-related incidents.

Apr 29, 2021
On the Police Logs 04.29.21

A Highway Behind the Pond resident was ticketed last Thursday for draining his pool water onto his neighbor's property, on Earth Day no less.

Apr 29, 2021
'Reckless' Pilot Can’t Fly for 90 Days

David Wisner, the pilot who flew his single-engine airplane in what local police have called "a dangerous and reckless manner over Sag Harbor Village" on April 13, has been charged with second-degree reckless endangerment and been suspended for 90 days from using East Hampton Airport.

Apr 29, 2021
East End Drug Task Force Busts 'Major' Drug Ring

Suffolk County District Attorney Timothy D. Sini announced Thursday that a drug trafficking ring based in Riverhead -- which investigators say also sold cocaine and other illegal substances in the Hamptons and in Brookhaven Town -- has been busted, landing 12 people in court.

Apr 26, 2021
On the Police Logs 04.22.21

A man was sitting on the train tracks near the East Hampton Railroad Station, a 911 caller reported on Tuesday evening. A responding officer found the man who said he lived in Riverhead standing on a sidewalk. He explained that he had been waiting for a bus and said he would stay off the tracks.

Apr 22, 2021
Bicyclist Thrown in Alleged D.W.I. Crash

This week, police arrested two drivers who were behind the wheel when they should not have been. Bonnie Rychlak, 69, of East Hampton was charged with both driving while intoxicated and having .08 of 1 percent alcohol or more in her blood on the night of April 11 when she hit and injured a bicyclist on Old Stone Highway near La Foret Lane, police said.

Apr 22, 2021
Low Flight Could Land Pilot a Court Date

A plane that flew as low as 50 feet above houses and businesses in Sag Harbor last week and prompted numerous 911 calls, may lead to a criminal charge for its pilot, David J. Wisner of East Hampton.

Apr 22, 2021
One Injured in Cedar Street Accident

In a three-car evening mix-up on April 14 at Cedar Street and Stephen Hand's Path in East Hampton, an 18-year-old East Hampton driver identified by police as W.A. Minchalabernal was injured after his car hit another vehicle and then struck a tree.

Apr 22, 2021
Montauk Fisherman and Wholesalers Indicted in Fraud Scheme

A federal grand jury has indicted two members of Montauk's Gosman family and a commercial fishing boat owner on charges of conspiracy to commit fraud and obstructing an investigation in connection with a scheme to sell at least $250,000 in illegally caught fluke and black sea bass. The United States Department of Justice announced the indictment on April 21.

Apr 21, 2021
Wainscott Man, 69, Charged

Mitchell Alfus, 69, of Wainscott was arrested and arraigned April 6 on misdemeanor charges of criminal obstruction of breathing and injuring a child less than 17 years old.

Apr 15, 2021