Skip to main content

Police & Courts

Other Drivers Called Police

A 31-year-old man was arrested on a drunken-driving charge on Saturday in Water Mill. Other motorists called Southampton Town police about a “reckless, erratic” driver on Montauk Highway around 10 p.m.

Apr 16, 2020
On the Police Logs 04.16.20

Police received a complaint on April 8 that respirator masks were being sold out of their original packaging and there was possible price gouging going on at a business on the Circle.

Apr 16, 2020
From Beer to Face Shields

Two North Fork companies are working together to provide face shields to fire departments, ambulance agencies, and hospitals across the East End for use when dealing with patients suspected of having Covid-19.     

Apr 16, 2020
On the Police Logs 04.09.20

Over on Pleasant Lane on Saturday, a resident reported that neighbors had arrived from New York City and had not quarantined, though the governor had recommended that anyone from the city quarantine for 14 days.

Apr 9, 2020
Two Crashes in 15 Minutes

Despite recommendations to stay home during the Covid-19 outbreak, several people were caught drinking and driving over the weekend, two on Sunday after accidents that occurred around the same time. 

Apr 9, 2020
Charged in Domestic Dispute

An East Hampton man was charged with a felony on March 31 following a domestic dispute. Noe W. Guaman-Nieves, 32, allegedly hit a woman in the face, despite an order of protection against him.

Apr 9, 2020
New Budget Restores Bail for Many Crimes

The final 2020-21 New York State budget, passed Friday, includes major “common sense” adjustments to the controversial criminal justice reforms enacted last year. 

Apr 9, 2020
Hailing Those on Front Line

Word spread like wildfire in a matter of hours: Go down to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital and make some noise for the health care workers combating Covid-19. 

Apr 9, 2020
‘Exhaustive Search,’ but Peter Beard Still Missing

Peter Beard, the 82-year-old artist and photographer, went missing from his home in Montauk last week, and the search has been scaled back with each passing day.

Apr 8, 2020
Dispatchers Are the First Line of Defense Against Covid-19

Answering calls and making sure that police and E.M.S. get as much information as possible to ensure safety.

Apr 7, 2020
Second East Hampton Town Police Officer Tests Positive for Covid-19

Chief Michael Sarlo said the officer, who he did not name, has been out since March 21 and self-quarantined after experiencing very mild symptoms.

Apr 6, 2020
Still No Sign of Peter Beard

"Certainly, as the hours turn to days the likelihood of a successful outcome diminishes, and we are keenly aware of that," East Hampton Town Police Capt. Chris Anderson said on Friday morning.

Apr 3, 2020
On the Police Logs 04.02.20

A customer at Red Horse Market was upset over the price of a case of water and caused a scene at about 3 p.m. on March 25. An employee called the police, but the woman was gone when they arrived.     

Apr 2, 2020
Felony Sex Abuse Charged

A resident at a Wainscott group home was arrested early Sunday morning for sexually abusing another resident.

Apr 2, 2020
Peter Beard Missing, Search Underway in Montauk

A search was ongoing in Montauk on Wednesday for the artist Peter Beard, who wandered away from his house near Montauk Point on Tuesday night. Mr. Beard is 82 and has dementia, according to police.

Apr 1, 2020
East Hampton Town Police Officer Recovering From Covid-19

An East Hampton Town police officer who was diagnosed with Covid-19 has made a full recovery and is ready to go back to work, The Star learned this week.

Mar 31, 2020
Firefighters Battle Flames, Coronavirus Concerns at East Hampton House Fire

Putting out the flames was not the only concern on firefighters' minds during a house fire on Sunday evening, as it was the first fire since the coronavirus outbreak. 

Mar 30, 2020
Motorcyclist Killed in Water Mill Crash

A New York City man was identified as the operator of a Kawasaki motorcycle that hit a tree in Water Mill on Saturday afternoon.

Mar 28, 2020
First Responders Consider Safety

As Covid-19 continues to spread, first responders on the South Fork are continuing to work, albeit while taking extra precautions. 

Mar 26, 2020
Rudolph Rando, 92     

Rudolph Rando of Montauk, who was known as Rudy, died of sepsis on Sunday at San Simeon by the Sound in Greenport.

Mar 25, 2020
Michael Lohan Arrested For Being With Wife, Despite Order

Michael Lohan, the father of the actress Lindsay Lohan, was arrested on March 16 in connection with a Feb. 22 incident at the Amagansett I.G.A.

Mar 25, 2020
Alleged Drunken Driver Tried to Leave the Scene

In Noyac, a drunken driver struck multiple vehicles on a property on Highview Drive on March 18 and then tried to leave the scene, Southampton Town police said. 

Mar 25, 2020
On the Police Logs 03.26.20

A woman stole a box of gloves from the East Hampton Urgent Care Center on March 15, according to a nurse who works there.

Mar 25, 2020
He Said, She Said: Who Will the Jury Believe?

Patchita Tennant broke down in tears on the witness stand Wednesday morning as she recounted the months leading up to the night when she shot and seriously injured her longtime boyfriend.  

Mar 19, 2020
Not Guilty! Former East Hampton CVS Manager Is Cleared on All Counts

Patchita Tennant stood silent until the foreman of the jury finished reading the verdict: not guilty on attempted murder and first-degree assault charges in the shooting of her longtime boyfriend, Andrew Mitchell. 

Mar 19, 2020
On the Police Logs

Reports included a missing driveway gate, a fallen neighbor's tree, a man drunk and disorderly, and a Springs prowler.

Mar 19, 2020
Patchita Tennant, Accused of Attempted Murder, Takes the Stand

It was an emotional day in court on Tuesday as Patchita Tennant took the stand to tell her side of what happened the night she shot her boyfriend, Andrew Mitchell. 

Mar 18, 2020
Most Courts Close, But Tennant Case Continues

Courthouses throughout Suffolk County, including East Hampton Town and Sag Harbor Village Justice Courts, are closing amid the spread of COVID-19, but the case against Patchita Tennant, a former East Hampton CVS manager accused of trying to murder her boyfriend, will press on.

Mar 16, 2020
Patchita Tennant's Boyfriend Testifies in Attempted Murder Case

Andrew Mitchell took the stand Friday morning, giving the jury its first glimpse into what happened on the evening of Sept. 5, 2019, when his longtime girlfriend, Patchita Tennant, shot him three times. 

Mar 14, 2020
On the Police Logs 03.12.20

Ten pieces of assorted lumber, stacked on sawhorses at Vincent Fiore’s Crassen Boulevard property, were stolen sometime between Feb. 15 and 18.

Mar 12, 2020